IGERT? What
the heck is IGERT?
It stands for Integrative Graduate Education Research, a program
invented by the National Science Foundation to improve the graduate
experience.
Can I apply if I am not a U.S. Citizen or Naturalized
Resident?
Sorry, but the answer is "no". Please apply instead to our
traditional graduate educational program by contacting the
department most closely allied to your research interests. If you
are accepted to LSU, you may experience many "spillover" benefits
from the IGERT project, but NSF guidelines forbid us from admitting
you into the IGERT program. International students can
participate in IGERT teams, though. We are disallowed from
providing stipend support or travel, but they may share other
benefits of the team.
What is Macromolecular Studies?
Good question! At LSU, we define it very broadly as the science
and engineering of polymers and biopolymers. It turns out that
certain concepts--for example, radius of gyration, loss modulus,
glass transition, electrophoresis, sedimentation--are important for
anyone who studies large molecules, supermolecular
structures, colloids, and materials made from all these. Our
curriculum is designed to take anyone with a reasonable background
in quantitative science or engineering and make them experts in this
area. Physicists will learn organic chemistry (a little!), organic
chemists will learn biochemistry (enough!), etc. This takes place
on top of the normal training in each student's home
department. You will be educated broadly and deeply. The reward
comes when you seek a job.
I'm a doctor, Jim, not a magician!
Poor Bones! That Star Trek doctor was always being thrust into
some situation for which he was underprepared. Don't let it happen
to you. Perhaps you are an analytical chemist. When you graduate,
you may be asked to work on macromolecules; about 50% of all
chemists work in polymers, prepared for it or not. That's because
it is a very, very long way from the tiny molecules you learned
about to most useful products. Or perhaps you want to make new,
improved drugs that Bones never imagined. These too are often large
molecules, as are the systems that deliver them, as is the
packaging. Planning to work on the human genome? DNA is a large
(huge!) molecule, as are most of the devices used to aid in its
sequencing. Interested in photonic bandgap materials? You don't
think they'll really be made from aluminum tubes for microwave
operation, do you? They will be made from polymers, as will be the
"smart" detectors in your next automobile, the packaging on that
next speedy Intel computer chip, and the disk for that new DVD
burner we'll all want soon. To you engineers destined to determine
the strength of composites, it actually does matter that
they are made of polymeric compounds. If you are a student
wondering whether or not you're macromolecular enough, have a
look at the research topics. Some of
our faculty also belong primarily to another discipline, spending
only a portion of their time with polymeric systems. Others are
world leaders in the polymer and biopolymer community. It's a
spicy Louisiana scientific gumbo, and that's what makes it work. If
you never heard of macromolecules before, you may be our ideal
student.
What are the employment opportunities in Macromolecular
Studies?
Outstanding. A major objective of NSF's IGERT program is to
train students in areas where industry, government and academic
institutions are experiencing a shortfall. The approval of our
proposal is itself proof that Macromolecular Studies is a hot
area. Our graduates may work in industries ranging from
pharmaceutics to petrochemicals, government laboratories devoted to
commerce, health or energy, small teaching colleges and major
research universities. An important benefit of the CMC program is
that students have opportunities to sample these locations during
their training. This makes it easier to decide which type of
environment is right for you. CMC-IGERT has contacts with the legal
and business communities and
entrepreneurship
certificate programs at LSU. Students aspiring to start their
own company, or work for a dot-com upstart, can prepare.
What if I get to LSU and find I want to do something else?
We won't understand it, but we will allow it. Each department
has a wealth of interesting topics to study. Indeed, one of the
things that makes Macromolecular Studies at LSU "click" is that we
do have such strong colleagues with whom to share ideas and
resources. Of course, IGERT resources are directed only towards
macromolecular students. If you do elect to leave the program, that
automatically returns you to a traditional support mechanism, but
these are very good.
What degree is offered?
Students receive Ph.D. degrees in their main area of study
(Biological Sciences, Chemistry, Chemical Engineering, Education,
Mechanical Engineering, Physics, Textiles, Veterinary Medicine).
Students are expected to abide by all the requirements of their home
departments. IGERT participation demands additional effort.
Students who complete all CMC-IGERT requirements qualify for a
degree certification in Macromolecular Studies (subject to
university approval).
I only want a master's degree. Is that possible?
No. If you intend to stop with a master's degree, please apply
for traditional support. We can also recommend other universities
in this case. Just call.
What is the take-home pay (i.e., after tuition) of an IGERT
fellow?
The Federally mandated minimum is $30,000/year plus tuition for a total support
package of about $34,500/year. Some IGERT students earn more than this.
No IGERT fellow gets more than $30,000/year from the IGERT grant
but some find other forms of support.
What determines the pay?
Not what but who! And the answer is...you!
IGERT is your chance to develop and practice entrepreneurship. But
not until the 2nd year.
During the first year, which may begin the summer before
fall classes start, you will probably be supported by non-IGERT
funds. The total take-home pay varies
according to the departmental commitment and teaching requirement,
but IGERT students. You may qualify for special awards from the
Graduate School or other on-campus sources, and IGERT does not
intefere with these. It may augment them, depending on
availability of funds! When you receive your
letter of acceptance, it will specify the exact compensation.
As your career advances, you can improve your financial situation
by finding special opportunities to collaborate with off-campus
laboratories. Some industrial partners provide extra compensation
for IGERT students. This can be quite lucrative, and it is an
excellent opportunity to see what industrial Ph.D. scientists do.
It also gets your foot in the door for a future job! Similar
opportunities exist in government labs. For example, if you were to
enter into a collaboration at the National Institutes of Standards
and Technology near Washington, DC, you would typically receive the
per-diem rate to support your stay there. But the reward isn't
really monetary: the real reward is the chance to do great
research at great facilities. You can also "scope out" a possible
"finishing school" experience (see below).
IGERT fellows are actively encouraged to seek other fellowships,
internships and grants (usually with their faculty co-advisors'
help). What we do in case they succeed depends on performance.
Example 1: an underperforming fellow finds $20,000 support
from another grant. We might reduce IGERT support to keep that
student at a total of $30,000 (this lets us place new applicants in
the program). Example 2: a superior IGERT fellow finds $20,000
support from another grant. We might not reduce IGERT
support very much or be able to devote more funds to minigrants or
other support to that student.
Either way, students in good standing remain eligible for minigrants
and other benefits of the program. You have nothing to lose by
trying to find your own funding, and everything to gain.
Another IGERT advantage is that teaching is not an "either-or"
proposition. You can retain your stipend AND add teaching to
supplement your income. We will probably not let you teach to the
exclusion of research, but if you have a need for extra cash, love
teaching, and have boundless energy, IGERT will not say "no". If
your performance suffers due to excessive teaching, we will
point that out.
What is the duration of the IGERT Fellowship
Usually between 2
and 4 years of stipend support, but students in good standing can
continue to write minigrants while on other forms of support.
They may also apply for "finishing school" experience near the end of
their graduate career. The situation is reviewed each semester.
What is apprenticeship? Why is it needed?
Apprenticeship is a short period in your graduate career during
which you will work directly with a senior investigator, usually
your research advisor. It is needed because, in traditional
graduate education, your advisor spends a lot of time finding money
for your support. You might be "trained" by senior graduate
students and/or postdoctoral researchers who scarcely know more than
you. IGERT gives the money to you directly, so your advisor has
more time to spend in the lab working with you. This is especially
important at the beginning of your career. Later, it's fully
expected that you work and think independently.
How do I get to be an apprentice?
During your first semester, you will hear presentations by IGERT
faculty who have developed a team research concept. The work must
be in a new area that neither faculty member could do
alone. (Ideally, you will become that new person with unique
talents to go it alone!). The faculty will describe the objectives,
off-campus research opportunities, other support for the project,
and interdisciplinary/interdepartmental skills required from the
graduate student team. They will also indicate where such
training leads in terms of permanent employment after you graduate.
Students interested in joining these teams will work together with
the faculty to devise a clear plan (we call it Form A) including what to do if one
student were to drop out, become ill, etc. The faculty
advisors also promise to give back to the program in some way (we
call that Form B). Midway through the first
semester, or at any time really, the faculty then go to the IGERT leadership and nominate
you as part of a team. If you are on-track with your coursework,
the IGERT committee will approve this nomination. Shortly
thereafter, you begin working side-by-side with your advisor on a "minithesis".
This will last 2-6 weeks and may or may not be related to your
eventual research project. It will culminate in a written report.
You get to see the entire research process--from startup to writeup--in
a short span of time. Getting your Ph.D. degree is then mostly a
matter of doing the same thing on a larger scale.
What if my team is not accepted?
Normally it will be, so don't worry! The worst case scenario is
that you are still a member of a great department, and will receive
the traditional levels of support it offers. Faculty can re-apply
immediately if a team project fails on the first try. The faculty
are well-versed in what it takes so, once again, do not worry.
What if I don't want to work in a team?
IGERT is not for you then. Please reconsider--it offers major
advantages. And don't worry--we planned ahead to give you plenty
of opportunity for individual creativity. You can even get your own
money and do what you wish, write the paper all by yourself, and
travel to a meeting to present it. But all that comes on top of the
team project.
What is an Artisan?
In traditional graduate programs, students take a qualifying exam
in year 2. The faculty determines whether the student is a
suitable candidate for the Ph.D. degree at this point. Most
students pass this exam. The CMC-IGERT program rewards passing by
giving you extra opportunities. Probably the most important is the
ability to write "minigrants"--small grants to support research
(suppose you have your own idea you wish to try); write a
single-authored paper (prestigious); travel to a great lab to learn
new methods; scout out a possible post-graduate opportunity, etc.
What is a Craftsperson?
IGERT Fellows who are about 6 months shy of defending their Ph.D.
will present their data (probably not completely written into thesis
form yet). This "data defense" gives the faculty an opportunity to
spot problems in time to correct them prior to the final defense.
Students who impress at this point are declared "Craftperson"--someone
who knows macromolecular systems from top to bottom, who can work
with their hands and mind and heart to the betterment of society
through science. Being so designated has a very tangible reward:
the student can do a "predoc" or "finishing school" experience at
another great laboratory anywhere in the world. It is even
possible to roam from one lab to another, looking at different ways
of doing things...and different places of possible future
employment. At our expense!
This is a great way to find out if that super scientist you have
been hoping to work for as a postdoc is also a good person. It
gives said super scientist the chance to see you, too, before
committing a lot of cash to your support. Use the finishing school
experience to see other great centers of macromolecular training,
make contacts for an academic or industrial or government career,
etc.
What extra responsibilities do I have as an IGERT student?
In addition to the normal requirements of your home department,
you must:
- Complete 3 of 4 core courses in Macromolecular Studies.
- Agree to work in interdisciplinary team research.
- Perform a small community service project.
Example 1: tutoring at-risk children (bona fide teachers will
guide you).
Example 2: help a high-school student with science fair
project.
Example 3: early identification of talent in colleges,
universities or elsewhere.
- Attend two short classes designed to raise the ethical
standard (Professional Conduct & Opportunities and Science and
Technology in Service to the Community). These classes await
university approval (likely).
- Attend IGERT seminars regularly.
- Keep proper records, including your likes and dislikes about
the program.
- Provide the IGERT statistician with information he needs to
evaluate the program.
- Participate in site visits from panels designed to test if our
IGERT is working.
Is it worth the trouble?
Absolutely! In addition to opportunities for
unprecedented pay, IGERT provides many other benefits.
- Minigrants to do your own research, write a single-authored
paper, travel to domestic and international meetings.
- Contacts, contacts, contacts! ("Gonnegtions", as they said in
"The Godfather").
- Off-campus co-advisors. World-famous experts who can help
you...and who will know you when it comes time to write those
letters of recommendation.
- Finishing school: you name the place with the coolest science
that you need to launch your career, and we'll send you there for
up to 6 months. Once you get your foot in the door, perhaps your
new home will find a permanent position for you. We think
potential employers will like what they see!
- Philosophy--IGERT is about putting the Ph. back in Ph.D. You
will be actively challenged to develop a philosophy of science and
teaching, through: challenging courses; early chances to exercise
creativity (hint: it doesn't always work out like you think!);
community service project to develop science that is relative to
the people who pay for it--consumers and taxpayers.
- Helping to reshape/improve graduate education. This is
especially important to students bound for an academic research
career. Our program may be among the best anywhere for such
students. Students headed for industry or government labs also
benefit from a great deal of practical education.
How long does it take?
Four to five years, but this largely depends on you!
Here's a typical timeline.
Does IGERT support last throughout my entire graduate
school career?
Not anymore. We originally
wanted to support students from cradle to graduation, but NSF will
not allow it. We hope that teams which started using new
students will use early results of your
research as preliminary data to support competitive grants to
Federal and private agencies. This enables the IGERT program to
admit new students, and provides you with a real feather in your cap
(a funded proposal will look great on your resume).
Typically, the new grant would pay for your salary and supplies, but
you would remain eligible--especially eligible, because you did
something great--for the other things IGERT provides, like
minigrants and finishing school.
Since about Fall of 2004, it has been our policy to use IGERT
funds to support the LAST 2-3 years for students who have
demonstrated their abilities, creativity and commitment by
participating in the program without stipend support as "IGERT
Associates".
You can get "kicked out" of IGERT--but only by deserving
it: repeated failure to attend seminars; blowing off your classes
(not trying--we admire those who try, and work with them until it
leads to success); failure to meet other commitments, such as the
community service project. "Kicked out" just means returned to a
traditional support program.
The best way to stay in the program is to use it: write
creative minigrants and do great things.
Who are some of your partners?
- DSM-Copolymer (Geleen, The Netherlands and Baton Rouge)
- Dupont (Wilmington, Delaware)
- Dow (Plaquemine, Louisiana and Freeport, Texas)
- Exxon (Baton Rouge)
- USDA Labs (New Orleans)
- Max-Planck Institute
(Mainz, Germany)
- Middle East Technical
University (Ankara, Turkey)
- General Electric (Indiana)
Must I be involved with these partners?
No! We are always trying to find new partners. Ideally, the
off-campus participant would take a very active role. The minimum
off-campus participation would be someone who serves as an expert
consultant on your faculty committee. They can come from any
first-rate science or engineering program--academic, industrial or
government.
I just interviewed at LSU and think I might be interested
in IGERT. How do I get started?
To become an IGERT student, please examine this very website
(http://igert.LSU.edu -- think of this site as the "Handbook for the
Recently Deceased" in the movie, Beetle Juice): confusing,
but it's all in there! Look at Chemistry, Biology, Physics,
Human Ecology and Chemical
Engineering web pages to see if there were two or more professors
here with whom you might consider working on an innovative new
project. Does NOT have to be the "officially macromolecular"
professors now on this website. We have students scattered all over
Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and other departments. Does the
personality of the place suit you? Ask yourself if you are willing
to do the extra stuff IGERT requires (the 4 low-key courses that mix
biologists, chemists, l engineers and others; the seminars; the
annual retreat; the ethics and community service stuff, and the
reporting forms). You can preview a lot of this from the IGERT
website plus the course website (http://russo.chem.LSU.edu/msweb).
There IS extra commitment to IGERT, but it works both ways: we are
extra-committed to seeing that you succeed. If, after all that, you
are still interested just let your host know so that we can factor
IGERT into your offer. IGERT offers always include an escape clause:
you can always resign your fellowship and become a teaching or
research assistant at the prevailing pay rate.
There is an "ideal" schedule for becoming an IGERT
student, but people find all kinds of different paths to us. We're
flexible. Here's the ideal: come during the summer ahead of
graduate school for 8 weeks of Macromolecular research and the Science & Technology in Service
to the Community course. The latter is a one-credit (about 2 hrs per
week for 8 weeks) easy course that looks at great successes and
failures of science, entrepreneurship, etc. The research is in one
or more of the nominally "macro" research labs. We pay you, and it's
pretty low key. No strings are attached, and you can back out of IGERT at any time. But we hope you use the time to work with IGERT-involved
faculty (this can be almost anybody) to start crafting an
innovative, interdisciplinary research plan or at least learn a bit
about Macro. Even though you might be working to create a new
project with 1 or 2 professors (maybe one of them is even in a
different department...or university!) you are required (some
departments) or encouraged (other departments) to interview with
other professors. Assuming they don't lure you away, you submit your
plan to the review panel (3 professors, one each in Chemistry,
Biological Sciences and Chemical Engineering). Most plans are
approved and then you become an "apprentice". It is NOT very hard to
write the plan, and your professors will help. There's even a form
for it--you can see several examples under "research" on the IGERT
web:
http://igert.lsu.edu/research.htm
Can a team consist of LSU professors and professors
elsewhere?
Yes. There must be at least one LSU professor involved and
each team must have an off-campus participant of some sort.
Most teams have two LSU professors involved, but we're keen on the
idea of reaching out to experts elsewhere.
IGERT seems very complex; is there a simple way for
students to know where they are in the program?
It IS complex. But we try not to get lost in the
details. We have introduced the "Milestone Checker", located at:
http://igert.lsu.edu/ActiveServerPages/CurrentStudents.asp
(By the way, several new students are not shown. We are always
behind; that's a characteristic of this thing--there is always too
much to do. Good students make it worthwhile, and the IGERT fellows
are really a nice group).
Questions from the August 8, 2002,
Working Lunch
“Team concept: when does it come into
effect?”
Well, it depends.
Ideally, 2 or more students with different backgrounds would form a
team with 2 or more PhD advisors with different backgrounds, on or off
campus. Ideally, that would happen right away. Sometimes, it takes
longer—especially to get the 2nd student member.
Another
interpretation of this question is, “When does a team actually DO
something as a team?” All the teams, including those on which I
participate, must work harder to encourage group activities.
Landmark activities such as grant writing and paper writing provide
other chances to work as teams. Symbolic or real rewards for team
activities—e.g., the SAXS tee shirts—can be paid for by the grant.
Still another
interpretation is, “When/how do we start making a team?” This
varies…and has to. If each student were to create his/her own
project, we’d never have any multi-student teams. A few very
creative students may invent teams in concert with faculty (this is
happening!) but this isn’t an English department or History
department yet. Also, it never can be—the stakes are too high for
technical research. More often the faculty participants have some
shared areas of interest. They suggest one or more possibilities to
prospective students interested in IGERT but leave many details out
to force the students to “fill in the blanks”. Almost nothing in
the technical undergraduate education system encourages independent
thought, so many students are not ready for this. Creativity
stimulating components later in IGERT should help students exercise
independent thought when they are ready.
“What are
guidelines for the director to tell the student what to do, without
inhibiting their freedom under the IGERT program?”
In principle,
IGERT students are working on an evolving team concept most of the
time. To encourage individual creativity beyond the team project,
Artisan-level students can write minigrants. Some of us remember
1970’s style industrial research at the better sites: scientists
were encouraged to spend about 1/4th of company time
pursuing their own ideas. If we agree that graduate students
should work 60+ hours per week, then perhaps 15+ hours per week on
average pursuing individual ideas makes sense. By the way, I was
very pleased to learn recently of a company that still encourages
creativity time. It offers hope that the stressful conditions
endured by industrial scientists in the 1990’s may be subsiding.
Questions related to the notion that IGERT students should
take an active role in defining their projects.
Are students really expected to design their own projects?
Good question--few first year scientists or engineers are mature
enough to design their own internationally competitive project.
This is because undergraduate science and engineering education
often does not emphasize original thought. That kind of maturity
is expected of English, History or Psychology graduate
students! Are they more creative than us, or have we in technology,
possibly because so much money is on the line, just gotten used to
the idea of students who do what they are told?
Some of both, probably, but creative students do exist and
we want LSU students to be able to compete with the best. Nobelist
Steve Chu tells a great story about the beautiful DNA tweezer work
his group did, which made the cover of Science. That work
was first suggested by a Stanford undergrad. A goal of IGERT is to
give our students chances to try their own ideas...while
leaving a safety net in place.
So, while we realize it is HARD for students to create their own
projects, it is still part of the IGERT experiment to see if we can
nudge them in that general direction. We are happy if IGERT students
negotiate with the professors, or at least take SOME active role in
defining the project, writing the proposal to IGERT, etc. Sometimes
we don't even get that! It is common that an IGERT student "merely"
facilitates a still-new research collaboration between a team of
faculty members who were thinking working together all along but did
not have the resources to start (they must have resources to do
whatever ELSE they are doing--unfunded professors are not bailed out
by IGERT).
We do recognize the special situation of assistant professors,
who need quick results in an area of their own design, yet sometimes
have not had enough time to secure independent support. Other
IGERT's also struggle with this. Ours is the first (we think) to
develop DIRT (Deferred Interdisciplinary Research Training). The
DIRT student initially works more or less on what the professor
suggests, as appropriate since that professor (or their department)
will be providing most of the support. Eventually, in return for
the partial support IGERT provides, the student will help the
assistant professor to locate and begin new interdisciplinary
collaborations, of benefit to both parties as their careers
develop.
Bottom line: The only thing that is strictly forbidden is for an
IGERT student to take on the research of a single faculty member--i.e.,
the "normal" graduate track. IGERT students who cannot immediately
demonstrate internationally-competitive creativity (that's almost
everyone!) will eventually be expected to do so.
Why would I, as a professor, help a student write the IGERT
starting proposal to pursue their crazy ideas, when my own funded
research is waiting to be done?
Spend your existing funds on fast postdocs or
international students who are not eligible for IGERT! Allowing
IGERT-interested students to pursue their own ideas--at IGERT
expense and with a fairly small time commitment from you--is key to
developing the next generation of creative scientists. You will
still have enormous influence, and might find new projects through
the interdisciplinary requirements of the programs.
How do I cite NSF-IGERT support in published work, oral
presentation or poster?
"This material is based upon work supported by the
National Science Foundation under Grant No. DGE-9987603"
For additional details about press releases, TV,
etc., see the NSF's Grant Proposal Guide: http://www.nsf.gov/pubsys/ods/getpub.cfm?gpg
|